Search

BLOG

Fee for Intervention – The Essentials Part Three Insights into HSE’s investigation from the FFI Notice

Blog image

In Part 1 we explained what Fee for Intervention (FFI) is, the controversy surrounding it and how it can affect businesses. In Part 2 we explained the process for challenging FFI.  This week in Part 3 we explain what you can learn from the information provided to a dutyholder through FFI about HSE’s views on the case and the scope of its investigation.

Notification of Contravention

Before HSE can charge under the Fee For Intervention regime the inspector must notify the dutyholder that there has been a material breach of health and safety legislation.  This will usually be by a notification of contravention or a notification of contravention served with an improvement/prohibition notice.

Before Fee For Intervention a company would not know what breaches of legislation were being considered by HSE and perhaps what issues HSE saw as key until a request was made by HSE for a representative of the company to be interviewed under caution. Even if an enforcement notice was served in the early stages of the investigation, at best, the company would learn the alleged breaches of legislation. 

HSE has three templates for a notification of contravention. Most common is the notification of contravention letter with stock paragraphs.  In the letter Appendix 1 will set out the alleged breaches of health and safety legislation and under each breach the inspector will set out their reasons for their opinion that a material breach has occurred. Because the inspector effectively has to justify their opinion of a material breach the information provided can be quite detailed.  This can not only reveal the outline of the case against the company but may also give an indication of the extent of the evidence the inspector has gathered.

Invoices

The invoices contain a breakdown of the work undertaken by HSE which is often quite detailed. Information that might be gleaned includes:

  • When inspectors undertook investigation work and the nature of that work         

  • Work undertaken by specialist inspectors including the writing of reports         

  • Whether other experts have been engaged          

  • Whether requests have been made to third parties for documentation.

This can be helpful in informing lines of enquiry to be made, considering the types of experts that may need to be retained and the classes of documents that be contained in the unused material if there is a prosecution.

Why is this information useful?   

Such insight can be extremely useful in a company’s preparations.  This is important because of the changing landscape: 

(i) The growing pressure for criminal cases to be expedited through the courts; 

(ii) the new health and safety sentencing guidelines which mean much higher fines in the future and 

(iii) the current proposals for the tightening of the rules for early guilty pleas with a steeper drop in percentage reduction the nearer the plea is entered to trial.

Therefore the more preparation that can be undertaken by the company’s defence legal team in the early stages of an investigation the better placed the company will be if proceedings are instigated in deciding on whether to plead guilty or defend and if the latter being able to take a proactive rather than a reactive approach to its defence.

Fisher Scoggins Waters are a London based law firm who are experts in construction, manufacturing and engineering matters.  We provide tailored advice and emergency response for health and safety matters occurring in these industries.  If you would like to discuss any points raised in this article, please phone us on 0207 993 6960.

Follow our company page on linkedin for future updates and our views on the latest developments

Categories: Health & Safety

Please leave a comment

Enter the name you would like to appear on the comment.
(required)
Enter the email you would like to use to get updates. You email is not visible and can not be used by other users.
(required)
Enter you comment help.

 
  Post Comment

Book Launch - 27 November 2019

Will you be joining us?

HSE and Environment Agency prosecution: A new climate

27 November 2019 | Bloomsbury, 50 Bedford Square, London, WC1B 3DP

Event Registration

First name
Surname
Email address
Any additional information
Post/Event URL
Post/Event Title
CAPTCHA image
Enter the code shown above in the box below.

Tag Cloud

‘fit for purpose’ obligations 2016 Adjudication adjudication lawyer Adjudication Notice Adjudication process appeal appointing an adjudicator Arbitration Artificial Intelligence Asbestos benefits of off-site construction bonfires book launch breach of contract Brexit Building Defects business interruption Business Interruption Insurance CDM CDM Regulations chambers and partners Charlotte Waters civil proceedings claim payments Claims client COMAH commercial contracts complex construction claims Compliance compulsory sprinklers in warehouses consequential loss construction Construction Construction & Engineering construction contract Construction contract dispute Construction contracts Construction dispute construction dispute lawyer construction dispute resolution construction dispute resolution solicitor construction dispute solicitors Construction Disputes Resolution Construction industry Construction Magazine contracts Contribution claim Corporate Manslaughter Corporate Responsibility costs criminal investigation criminal proceedings cut out fuse Defective Building Work Defective Premises Act developer developers disadvantages of off-site construction Disaster disaster claim Disasters Dispute dispute resolution Disputes DPA Dr Louise Smail Emergency response Emergency Response Solicitors enforcement notices Engineering Engineering dispute Environment Agency environment law Environmental Environmental Agency Environmental damage Environmental Law environmental waste EU EU Procurement Europe Evidence Expert evidence expert witness falls from height Fatal Accidents fee for intervention Fees For Intervention FFI FIDIC Contracts fine Fines Fire Fire Claim fire claims fire damage fire damage lawyers fire sprinkler systems fireworks flood flood claim flood damage food hygiene Fracking fracking claims Fraudulent claims FSW Gross Negligence Manslaughter Guide to Adjudication H&S fine increases; health and safety fines; Health & Safety health & safety breach health & safety sentences health & safety sentencing guidelines health & safety sentencing large corporations health and safety health and safety Health and Safety Executive heave Higher Fines Honey Rose v R How to appoint an adjudicator HSE Insolvency insolvent insurance Insurance Act 2015 insurance bill Insurance Broker insurance claim insurance cover Insurance Disclosure Insurance Disclosure insurance dispute insurance dispute solicitors Insurance Warranties ISO 45001 join us joint venture Judicial Review latest news Law Lawyer legal 500 legal advice privilege Legal Expense Insurance legal professional privilege legal retainers Liability Liquidated Damages Litigation litigation privilege local bodies magistrates’ courts Major Property Damage Manufacturing Martinisation material breach Mediation Michael Appleby Micheal appleby modern methods of construction (MMC) modular construction Mr. Gutaj Notice of adjudication panel firms party wall Performance Bond planning powers of an adjudicator pre-fabrication procurement procurement injunction procurement model Property Damage property danage Public Contract Public Contracts Public Contracts Regulations public procurement public procurement challenges public procurement relationship public sector Publicity Order PUWER recruitment regulation 11 Relief Resolution riot Riot Compensation Act 2016 Risk Risk Assessment safety in the workplace Sanctions Self-build sentence sentencing sentencing guidelines Serious Fraud Office SME Sneller Sony specialist risk and safety consultant Statute Barred Sub-Contractors subrogation subsidance subsidence TCC TCC Guidance team Technology and Construction Court The Adjudicator’s Decision and Costs The Enterprise Act The Lord Young Reforms The Powers Of An Adjudicator The Public Contracts Regulations 2015 The referral notice and response Training tree root UK Underwriters Warehouse insurance Warranties waste water damage WEEE What is Adjudication? what should an adjudication refal notice contain work equipment

Search The Site

Accreditations

 

The Legal 500 - The Clients Guide to Law Firms


Contact Us Now For Advice And Guidance

Enter your name
Enter your surname
Enter your Email
Ask us a Question?